Discussion about this post

User's avatar
Karin Kohlmeier's avatar

No offense to Mr. Welsh (truly), but am I the only one who's bored to tears with this whole narrative that anything older than 10 years old "couldn't be made today"? (Mindy Kaling recently said that The Office was too subversive to be made now, for god's sake.) Tons of incredible, interesting things are being made all the time. Including subversive things. I just watched a movie from 2022 (Fresh) in which a guy kidnaps women and keeps them alive to carve them up and sell their body parts to cannibals. To name just the first example that comes to mind. Hell, if Greener Pastures had been written 20 years ago, there would be blog posts lamenting how it couldn't be written today. Guaranteed.

I'd be interested to know what Welsh means by the "homogenization of culture" that's supposedly happening now. Because we're in a time where a Pakistani-Canadian non-binary person can get an HBO series (again, just to name one example). That sure seems like the opposite of cultural homogenization to me.

Expand full comment
Brandan's avatar

‘Trainspotting’ was one of a number of books that got me back into literature big time when I was 15 or 16. I remember getting it and a copy of its sequel, ‘Porno’, from the store HMV. Binged through the two books, loved them, then went and read the rest of Welsh’s work.

It’s depressing but not surprising to see that Welsh thinks there’d be some issue with ‘Trainspotting’ getting published today. The self published book that later gets picked up by a publisher if it gets enough attention is an interesting topic. Do you think that’d be a something you’d be interesting in discussing at length in a future post, Chuck?

Expand full comment
53 more comments...

No posts