42 Comments
User's avatar
User's avatar
Comment deleted
Jan 18, 2025
Comment deleted
Chuck Palahniuk's avatar

Yeah, you're here. Keep your expectations low.

User's avatar
Comment deleted
Jan 18, 2025
Comment deleted
Chuck Palahniuk's avatar

Chelsea Cain once ran down a guy on Hawthorne. The police taught her how they determine the point of impact by where the shoes fell off.

Being a NYT bestselling author, she was immediately cleared of all blame and feted by the detectives at the scene. Such are the perks.

User's avatar
Comment deleted
Jan 17, 2025
Comment deleted
Chuck Palahniuk's avatar

Thank YOU. The longer I live, the more I'm enchanted by phrases my grandparents and great grandparents used. "Who died and made you the King of England." Or, "She got my Irish up." Or, "Everything he owns is on his back."

Such phrases tend to be physical and intuitive. Not to mention how they resurrect the beloved dead.

Alison Bull's avatar

I read Bonfire ages ago, but the one passage I remember is the description of the two attorneys in the Bronx eating their massive sub sandwiches, their mouths opening unnaturally wide. I probably remember this because I’m Italian and from New Jersey and this is how people eat subs. Wolf got that one right.

Justine's avatar

Not if you have TMJ...

Chuck Palahniuk's avatar

It's 650 pages. I'm at page 125, and Wolfe has only introduced two main characters and one plot point.

Chuck Palahniuk's avatar

And no female POV characters. By midway it does become a slog as the scenes devolve into arranging chairs and staging long, long talks between characters.

Wolfe's forte is the insights he offers -- I'd no idea the Irish referred to themselves as "harps" and "donkeys." But once the courtroom drama gains momentum, those rich insights peter out.

Chuck Palahniuk's avatar

And no female POV characters. By midway it does become a slog as the scenes devolve into arranging chairs and staging long, long talks between characters.

Wolfe's forte is the insights he offers -- I'd no idea the Irish referred to themselves as "harps" and "donkeys." But once the courtroom drama gains momentum, those rich insights peter out.

Sean Bohl's avatar

The weird things that hang out in our subconscious are wonderful. I love the problem solving that happens when i give an idea or issue room to ferment in my mind. This post is a cool insight into your process. Thank you.

Chuck Palahniuk's avatar

It's tough to call it "process" because so much seems to be automatic or intuitive. An attempt to recreate what was engaging when I first began reading. The effects, if not the stories themselves.

Foremost were the smarmy short stories in mainstream magazines like Redbook or Family Circle or Reader's Digest. That's an upcoming post.

Jake Gardner's avatar

The moment I started reading this, I thought ‘Avocado!’ I appreciate all these techniques you give us. I’ve found myself using them unexpectedly, and I love that. They aren’t consciously employed, just available when they’re perfect for the story. Like practicing scales.

Chuck Palahniuk's avatar

Exactly. When you hit a moment that needs -- something. Then you have the greatest variety of textures to consider: A list? Big voice? Revisit the object? A montage? On the body? Or some odd fireworks like Hernia, hernia, hernia.

Brandan's avatar

Rhythm and stylistic repetition in writing becomes more apparent to me in its effectiveness the more I realise just how much of it stays with me years after reading it compared to other types of prose.

I love the way Charles Bukowski describes rhythm in writing and how each line should contain it’s own “juice/flavour” from 1:17 - 1:36 in this clip: https://youtu.be/fo9CQT3hXu8?feature=shared

Brandan's avatar

Bim, Bim, Bim,

Bim, Bim, Bim,

Bim, Bim, Bim,

Bim, Bim, Bim

Chuck Palahniuk's avatar

Wow, I agree fully. How often have I read 600-page novels, wading through long scenes, only to find the "grand emotion" flat and exhausted?

Cheap & Crass's avatar

I'm reading your 'Stranger Than Fiction" and I'm pretty sure the "Testy Festy" story will haunt me for the rest of my life.

Chuck Palahniuk's avatar

That bar has long since been demolished. The town of Clinton, Montana is now a McMansion suburb of Missoula.

That's part of the impulse to document the margins. While reading Wolfe's "Kandy-Kolored Tangerine-Flake Dream Machine" I recalled the 90s "art cars" that were the mascot of the Cacophony Society. It feels good to have written about such cars because now they're gone. Bristling with glued-on stuff, they were a big middle-finger to aerodynamics and good taste and resale value. Wolfe would've loved them.

Cheap & Crass's avatar

Oh How interesting! I've seen a few art cars in Nor Cal. One had barbie heads clued all over it. It was special. Do you have pictures?

Chuck Palahniuk's avatar

Ah, I wish. As of now I know of only Marcy's derelict art car, rusting on flat tires beside her house. Encrusted with a thousand... bowling trophies?

Cheap & Crass's avatar

Awww...lol that's awesome though!

Eric Iversen's avatar

Hell, you told a story about someone unsuccessfully trying to save a kid and without realizing the genesis of the idea, I wrote a story about someone trying to save a kid with CPR. I didn't realize where the story idea was generated until you reminded me.

Not a lifted technique, but a lifted idea.

"And so it goes"

"Where was I"

"Start. Again"

Chuck Palahniuk's avatar

Hey, I lifted it from the real people at my gym who LIVED IT. Good ideas create their own lives in the world.

RPG Elise's avatar

I remember that prompt in the stack!

Kelly Clark's avatar

I got to the long avocado scene while driving so I heard it on audiobook. That is a thing!

Chuck Palahniuk's avatar

Word is that the British actor did an excellent job. I hope you panicked and thought your player might be broken.

Kelly Clark's avatar

He really did. I panicked because I couldn't believe how long it went on and I couldn't take it anymore! I finally found a some references to the possible Ted Bundy victim in Milwaukie. It was in July 1973. Her name was Laurie Lee Canady. She was either 15 or 18, but she did get pushed out of a car onto the sidewalk at McLoughlin and SE Scott St. There are various versions, including the spelling of her name as Canaday. It sounds likely he was killing as early as 1972, and he had a lot of free time then. I still can't find the original source I heard ages ago that said she was shoved from a VW bug at 2 a.m. in front of a funeral home, but Peake Funeral Chapel used to be at SE Scott and McLoughlin. He's suspected in other cases in PDX at that time too.

RPG Elise's avatar

Just got done reading The Dog Stars and now reading Burn. I am starting to see tools from the stack in fiction, which is pretty cool. The Dog Stars definitely has one of those Ira Levin style moments where you want to tell the character, "Don't do it!" Something I want to learn how to pull off in writing.

RPG Elise's avatar

Also totally derailed by the road kill deer leg in the mail!?!? Like a real deer leg? Was it a consensualy sent deer leg? Taxidermy or the real deal?

Chuck Palahniuk's avatar

Still have yet to open the box. My back porch feels like the final scene in Se7en.

RPG Elise's avatar

I am so sorry! Not sure I would ever be ready for the deer leg kind of mail.

Bryan Wiler's avatar

In my pre-Plot Spoiler days, writing tips and suggestions were breadcrumbed around the places I spent time - a napkin in the junk drawer (we all have one), a notebook that must be around here somewhere, a voice note that I was positive got recorded on this phone but I guess it must have been the last one. Then I got more serious about writing, thanks to escaping a corporate job and then stumbling upon Substack...Chuck's page, in particular. A note in my phone grew fat with dozens of concepts, tips, and theories on how to be a better writer. I read those notes every time I sat down to write, until I didn't. The goal with learning is to turn the conscious into the subconscious. That happened, at least for some of Chuck's wisdom.

Vince Roman's avatar

Thanks for sharing this, Chuck

Oliver's avatar

George Saunders had a similar thought in an old newsletter. Something along the lines of: it’s tough to teach why I do this in my writing, because it’s a technique I absorbed but don’t remember why it works.

We should all try to write so much until we write all the bad writing out of our systems and only the good writing is left. Until it’s second nature.

Craig Father Of Kittens's avatar

I see lots of effective use of rhyme alliteration and repetition in the children’s books that are fun to read more than once.

My daughter quite liked a recent one by David Sedaris “Pretty Ugly” about a little ogre girl.